Finally got around to read this one.
Hmmm...did he pass??..not very good at all. Way way too many assumptions, just to get some "numbers". The SLICE hull configuration he uses is nothing like the actual SLICE.
Nowhere does he show units...terrible. Defeitions are hard to find.
Does not show any actual data of an actual hull form, just numbers from geometry. So ok, lets see what those numbers mean. His displacement length ratio is all to cock....the numbers are meaningless. Since if i use the actual SLICE values with his D/L ratio, the actual length of Lider, shown in previous post would be 8m long!!!
Only 9 references too. I had some 150 ref's and 300 bibliography for my Masters thesis.