Stephen Ditmore
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jun 12, 2001
- Posts
- 1,634
- Reaction score
- 77
- Location
- South Deerfield, MA, USA
Open 60 & 50 (IMOCA) rule should be changed
Don't get me wrong.... I'm a fan of IMOCA Open 60 and 50 class racing, the people who race these boats, the designers who design them, and the nation (France) that has embraced and supported this sport. But I see a problem with the rule; a quirk that (like quirks in the IOR rule) will drive designers to design even more freakishly wide boats. Designers coming into the game, such as Kouyoumjian, are realizing that there may be no optimum beam within the envelope of parameters represented by the current IMOCA fleet.
In many ways these boats are akin to giant dinghies, with movable ballast taking the place of crew weight shift as the major source of stability, and therefore sail carrying capability, at the fastest angles of heel. The amount of movable ballast is limited by rule D2 (attached).
To keep the math simple, compare two 60 footers, one with a 13 foot (4m)beam, another with a 26 foot (8m) beam. The waterline beams also in a 2:1 ratio, the displacements same, and the center of gravity near the upright center of buoyancy in both cases. GM will be roughly equal to BM = KLB^3 / displacement, so the wider boat will have 8 times the initial stability, and will therefore be allowed to generate 8 times the amount of righting moment from movable ballast (perhaps using 4 times the amount of ballast on twice the transverse lever).
There's a better way to limit movable ballast. Base allowed HM(movable) on most unfavorable RM(90) [not RM(10)]. This will take beam out of the equation and put the emphasis on vertical center of gravity, where it should be. Since there are tests that require the boat to be tipped on its side already, RM(90) would be an easy thing to measure, as would HM(movable), using a crane with load cell.
Make this change, and the financial horsepower of sponsored racing and the mental and computational horsepower of IMOCA development class designers can be harnessed to produce seaworthy boats converging, over time, toward a meaningful optimum (as open class boats should). Fail to make it, and these boats will increasingly become freaks created by a quirk in the rule under which they race.
I'd be especially interested in reactions from French and other European participants in these forums. Do you agree with me? Is there discussion of this quirk, and whether it should be fixed?
I would note that this does not apply to Class40, since Class40 does not allow canting keels and limits water ballast by weight alone, independent of beam. Also because Class40 has a sail area limit.
Don't get me wrong.... I'm a fan of IMOCA Open 60 and 50 class racing, the people who race these boats, the designers who design them, and the nation (France) that has embraced and supported this sport. But I see a problem with the rule; a quirk that (like quirks in the IOR rule) will drive designers to design even more freakishly wide boats. Designers coming into the game, such as Kouyoumjian, are realizing that there may be no optimum beam within the envelope of parameters represented by the current IMOCA fleet.
In many ways these boats are akin to giant dinghies, with movable ballast taking the place of crew weight shift as the major source of stability, and therefore sail carrying capability, at the fastest angles of heel. The amount of movable ballast is limited by rule D2 (attached).
To keep the math simple, compare two 60 footers, one with a 13 foot (4m)beam, another with a 26 foot (8m) beam. The waterline beams also in a 2:1 ratio, the displacements same, and the center of gravity near the upright center of buoyancy in both cases. GM will be roughly equal to BM = KLB^3 / displacement, so the wider boat will have 8 times the initial stability, and will therefore be allowed to generate 8 times the amount of righting moment from movable ballast (perhaps using 4 times the amount of ballast on twice the transverse lever).
There's a better way to limit movable ballast. Base allowed HM(movable) on most unfavorable RM(90) [not RM(10)]. This will take beam out of the equation and put the emphasis on vertical center of gravity, where it should be. Since there are tests that require the boat to be tipped on its side already, RM(90) would be an easy thing to measure, as would HM(movable), using a crane with load cell.
Make this change, and the financial horsepower of sponsored racing and the mental and computational horsepower of IMOCA development class designers can be harnessed to produce seaworthy boats converging, over time, toward a meaningful optimum (as open class boats should). Fail to make it, and these boats will increasingly become freaks created by a quirk in the rule under which they race.
I'd be especially interested in reactions from French and other European participants in these forums. Do you agree with me? Is there discussion of this quirk, and whether it should be fixed?
I would note that this does not apply to Class40, since Class40 does not allow canting keels and limits water ballast by weight alone, independent of beam. Also because Class40 has a sail area limit.