Trip the Light: Quote: “The West system impregnates wood with epoxy absorbing the resin and effectively using the grain as the structure like matt in fibreglass, [*] it turns wood into plastic sort of”
The author meant well I’m sure, but I need to correct this
far too common assumption.
I have worked with epoxy since its inception (post
Adagio~1970) and used it since for numerous boats and other items too.
While epoxy is a wonderful product and can last many years and is ideal for bonding and creating joints etc., is does NOT impregnate wood to any worthwhile degree and most certainly cannot turn wood into any sort of plastic! In fact, after the first coat is applied, the wood is now mostly sealed
against any absorption, so IF there’s any penetration, the first coat is critical.
So can the first coat of epoxy be thinned for this purpose? Well, some 20 years ago, WEST System published a detailed article about the effects of thinning epoxy in their seasonal magazine
EpoxyWorks. I will try to summarize what I remember of that, for readers who may have missed it. As it came from WEST System themselves, I think it’s worth noting.
Epoxy
can be thinned with acetone (or lacquer thinner) but its strength properties are affected. (I’d recommend to
never use more than 3% thinner - which will already lower initial viscosity by about half and cut strength by 20%). But if used in a concentrated area, such as to repair rotten wood, solvent can become trapped in, causing the epoxy to shrink over time … leading to cracks that will then allow water in!
If one insists, a better way to thin is to keep the resin at least at room temperature and then warm the surface to be coated …. say up to about 110 deg F .., that’s warm to the touch, but certainly not hot. After the resin is applied, the
material then cools and the resin is drawn in ‘a little’. (As’ drawing-in’ takes time, you’ll need to use the slowest hardener for this). But as will be noted, this is really only justified to get a little extra strength for joints made with very hard woods.
Epoxy will
never impregnate as one might wish it to. I have over-coated numerous material samples and once cured, sliced them to examine the penetration under a magnifying glass. It’s seldom visible. In fact, it’s only
very hard woods like oak, maple, birch etc that will gain
anything from first starting with a thinned epoxy, as the bond to just the surface of a softer, weaker wood (especially like cedar), will already be much stronger than the actual inter-fiber strength of the wood itself. And it’s worth remembering that the strength still
comes
from the wood fibers themselves, so if you’re repairing rotten wood, you are only making the repair
hard, you’re not making it stronger, unless you also add on fiber like fiberglass, Kevlar or carbon.
So plan on using epoxy as the manufacturer suggests … using several coats to build-up a waterproof membrane … but first make sure the surface is dry, free of oil & dust, and at least at room temperature.
The less joints and sharp corners you have, the more continuous and effective that barrier will be. Solvents can cause more trouble than they are worth and will weaken the strength of the epoxy. Too much complex framing is also a problem, as
any coating system struggles to protect corners ... see more below.
Because of a rash of ‘penetrating epoxies’ that came on the market a few years ago, WEST System were forced to defend their case, so their chemist wrote a more recent article on “
the penetrating epoxy myth”, that reiterated most of the facts from their earlier article of 20 years back.
You’ll find it here:
Penetrating epoxy: legend or myth? .... https://www.epoxyworks.com/index.php/penetrating-epoxy-legend-myth/
Personally, my approach is to try and build structures with the lowest length of sharp corners, the least number of softwood parts, to presheath the interior side of plywood before it’s built in and finally, make sure that end grain will stay well sealed for the life of the project. To help achieve this, I came up with the cleaner, simpler way to build with flat panels (for my
W17 trimaran) and anyone interested can search for this ‘
ABC System’ on my website. (Just use the Google search panel). There’s nothing for sale .. it’s simply free advice if it interests you … as are the other 180+ articles posted there.
Hope this helps someone.
www.smalltridesign.com