johnnythefish
Junior Member
- Joined
- May 25, 2016
- Posts
- 74
- Reaction score
- 13
- Location
- E.A.
So here is a 19 foot Stitch and Glue Center console that I build from plans by Jacques Mertens (Classic 19 (C19) - Study Plans https://bateau.com/studyplans/C19_study.php?prod=C19).
Unfortunately, I had some issues with one batch of epoxy resin that never cured. I only discovered this several years after launching. Cut a long story short, I had to gut the inside of her as the layer of biaxial cloth that sheathed the inside of the hull - to which the stringers were bedded - had started to lift off. I was using a very viscous epoxy resin for the inside (as I had run out of the Gurit SP106 that I used on the outside of the hull). This was all that was locally available - and I believe there were batches when we sheathed the inside that were either not mixed properly or the ratio was out. The issue was hidden by the fact that we worked wet on wet and the top layers cured firm and hard and I never noticed that beneath were some batches than stayed uncured for years.
Anyways ... I had always wished that I had built a slightly longer boat. I cannot fault the C19 in any ways as far as "doing what it said it would" on the box. But over time as I became more familiar with boats and what I was using it for, I realized that I should perhaps have gone for a longer, thinner hull... more of a "Panga" than a classic planning hull.
Much of my time is spent fishing in the boat - trolling lures at 8 kts which is about the worst speed for a hull of this shape in terms of fuel usage.
I have read what I can on the subject of boats - I thoroughly enjoyed David Gerr's "The Nature of Boats" - but I must say that I start to glaze over when hard-core mathematical formula come out! I have been particularly interested in Tom Lathrops "Bluejacket boats" - and how he went about attempting to achieve a boat that transitioned to the plane nicely, with little hump and minimal change of trim angle. The fact that he does this with a Constant deadrise hull is also interesting.
Well... I have decided to extend my C19... at the very least I gain more space and a bigger boat and I come out of my gutting process with some semblance of feeling like "oh well ... maybe it was for the best"...
My hopes are that she will be lighter for her size (I am planning on keeping weight as low as possible) and possibly, I will see some improvement in her "efficiency" at the 8 kt trolling speeds (though I am under no illusions here).
The designer is happy with a 10% scaling up of his plans from scratch - so that would be about 2 feet - but he also is happy with a bolt on armstrong type bracket... so the optimist in me feels that stretching the hull 4 feet wouldn't be totally unreasonable!! That I believe would make some serious differences to how she would behave - and given that I am sticking with the same engine, fuel quantities, fishing buddies etc, I would have a boat that was relatively much lighter in the water.
I have cut the transom off ... so there is no going back now...
The extension will be done from the transom end - and as you can see I have cut the hull so that I can add a lower side panel first that follows the hull contours and takes its shape from the topside panel. The stringers will be extended and the existing transom returned but trimmed down to fit the slightly narrower stern created by the slight curve as the hull panels extend back. The hull bottom will then be then cut to fit into this - ensuring I keep everything straight and avoid any hook or rocker, I feel like it should turn out OK!!
I am planning to add between one and two frames (depending on what final length I decide on). I am also going to add a skeg - as the boat is quite hard to steer at slow speeds and in wind. I will butt join the panel overlaps and have a frame right above this. I will also extend the lifting strakes across the joint. I will keep the lamination schedule the same.
All the gaps between stringers and frames will be foam filled for added stiffness (and safety reasons).
I guess the all important question is to all of you who are wiser and more experienced at this than I am .... how many feet should I add on?!!
Here are some pics of a temporary mock up I made out of plywood... 2 feet and 3 feet shown...
Part of me feels that adding 4 feet will get me closer to what I want to achieve - but I am worried that at a certain point, I am pushing my luck with the strength of the hull and the scantlings would need to be increased.
Any thoughts and comments most deeply appreciated!!
Unfortunately, I had some issues with one batch of epoxy resin that never cured. I only discovered this several years after launching. Cut a long story short, I had to gut the inside of her as the layer of biaxial cloth that sheathed the inside of the hull - to which the stringers were bedded - had started to lift off. I was using a very viscous epoxy resin for the inside (as I had run out of the Gurit SP106 that I used on the outside of the hull). This was all that was locally available - and I believe there were batches when we sheathed the inside that were either not mixed properly or the ratio was out. The issue was hidden by the fact that we worked wet on wet and the top layers cured firm and hard and I never noticed that beneath were some batches than stayed uncured for years.
Anyways ... I had always wished that I had built a slightly longer boat. I cannot fault the C19 in any ways as far as "doing what it said it would" on the box. But over time as I became more familiar with boats and what I was using it for, I realized that I should perhaps have gone for a longer, thinner hull... more of a "Panga" than a classic planning hull.
Much of my time is spent fishing in the boat - trolling lures at 8 kts which is about the worst speed for a hull of this shape in terms of fuel usage.
I have read what I can on the subject of boats - I thoroughly enjoyed David Gerr's "The Nature of Boats" - but I must say that I start to glaze over when hard-core mathematical formula come out! I have been particularly interested in Tom Lathrops "Bluejacket boats" - and how he went about attempting to achieve a boat that transitioned to the plane nicely, with little hump and minimal change of trim angle. The fact that he does this with a Constant deadrise hull is also interesting.
Well... I have decided to extend my C19... at the very least I gain more space and a bigger boat and I come out of my gutting process with some semblance of feeling like "oh well ... maybe it was for the best"...
My hopes are that she will be lighter for her size (I am planning on keeping weight as low as possible) and possibly, I will see some improvement in her "efficiency" at the 8 kt trolling speeds (though I am under no illusions here).
The designer is happy with a 10% scaling up of his plans from scratch - so that would be about 2 feet - but he also is happy with a bolt on armstrong type bracket... so the optimist in me feels that stretching the hull 4 feet wouldn't be totally unreasonable!! That I believe would make some serious differences to how she would behave - and given that I am sticking with the same engine, fuel quantities, fishing buddies etc, I would have a boat that was relatively much lighter in the water.
I have cut the transom off ... so there is no going back now...
The extension will be done from the transom end - and as you can see I have cut the hull so that I can add a lower side panel first that follows the hull contours and takes its shape from the topside panel. The stringers will be extended and the existing transom returned but trimmed down to fit the slightly narrower stern created by the slight curve as the hull panels extend back. The hull bottom will then be then cut to fit into this - ensuring I keep everything straight and avoid any hook or rocker, I feel like it should turn out OK!!
I am planning to add between one and two frames (depending on what final length I decide on). I am also going to add a skeg - as the boat is quite hard to steer at slow speeds and in wind. I will butt join the panel overlaps and have a frame right above this. I will also extend the lifting strakes across the joint. I will keep the lamination schedule the same.
All the gaps between stringers and frames will be foam filled for added stiffness (and safety reasons).
I guess the all important question is to all of you who are wiser and more experienced at this than I am .... how many feet should I add on?!!
Here are some pics of a temporary mock up I made out of plywood... 2 feet and 3 feet shown...
Part of me feels that adding 4 feet will get me closer to what I want to achieve - but I am worried that at a certain point, I am pushing my luck with the strength of the hull and the scantlings would need to be increased.
Any thoughts and comments most deeply appreciated!!