Simple and simplistic stability test of an humble RC Boat

Hi again,

(off topic alert!)

I will, and thank you. But I'm kind of a "scatter-brain" because of a muscle condition/damage in my throat. Most of the time I'm somewhat (not totally)"out there", and other times I work well. As a result I don't always accumulate information very well at times. I'm saving my progress to the periods where I work well. In my world things take time at times:-). But I do enjoy the mental stimulus of boat design when things are not ocean-colored aka "the blues":-)
 
Well done.

Receiving a compliment from an industry professional such as Gonzo is not to be taken lightly, he is wired to consider worst cases and warn you of your folly; and choses praises instead.

TANSL has made a kind offer and the site admin can possibly fix your title if you tell him what you want.

Is there an intention to build full size? This could be a massive thread like the sea sled one. He basically resurrected and modernised a ~100 year old fairly unique planing hull design and built it full size as a work boat.

Carry on! Looking forward to progress.
 
Well done.

Receiving a compliment from an industry professional such as Gonzo is not to be taken lightly, he is wired to consider worst cases and warn you of your folly; and choses praises instead.

TANSL has made a kind offer and the site admin can possibly fix your title if you tell him what you want.

Is there an intention to build full size? This could be a massive thread like the sea sled one. He basically resurrected and modernised a ~100 year old fairly unique planing hull design and built it full size as a work boat.

Carry on! Looking forward to progress.
Hi and thanks.

Compliments are appreciated indeed, and constructive critique as well. I will definitely take advise from the knowledgeable people here on the forum.

As regarding the title... who cares about indefinite articles anyway:-)

I will most probably only build models, but I do entertain myself with the idea sometimes. But I am also somewhat of a realist (hard to notice some times, though). I might have been able to pull it of some day, but that is not a driver. I don't have the cards:-)

I will continue to post when I feel I have something to show, or ask advice where needed.
 
Another hull I made a while back. Scale 1/12.59. In this case I've given the hull a weight of 4.5kg (centered at red dot) and ballast of 5.47kg (centered at yellow dot). I used Ship Workbench to find Sink and Trim and GZ


Newhull_01.webp
Newhull_02.webp
Newhull_03.webp
 
Gif animation showing sink and trim with FreeCAD Ship Workbench

Sink_and_Trim_FC_Ship_WB.gif
 
Tested the stability with Ship workbench. Last picture is of peak of curve.

Well...no.
Your boat has an open cockpit (no deck is shown)...ie..water will flooded it once the gunwhales are immersed.

From around here:
1790298867287.webp


At any angle beyond this, the cockpit will flood. There is no deck.
Thus the curve will be more like this:
1790298918844.webp


Roughly guessing at which angle this is occurring...
 
Well...no.
Your boat has an open cockpit (no deck is shown)...ie..water will flooded it once the gunwhales are immersed.

Roughly guessing at which angle this is occurring...
Well, here at 50.5 deg heel, it looks like the diagram is spot on if you ask me. You can argue the stability would be better without deep deck, and I will agree. And yes, the last picture actually was peak curve. You picked the wrong picture for argument.

discuss_00.gif
 
It looks like at 55 degrees the gunwale is under water.
 
It looks like at 55 degrees the gunwale is under water.
Yes it is. I'm not sure how the boat carries the water it separates or lift away from the main body of water (ocean), which it hasn't done here. But one can clearly see on the diagram where the diminishing increase in stability towards Peak curve, because of the deck shape. I'm open for suggestion to my understanding. And the gunwale have buoyancy too.
 
Yes it is. I'm not sure how the boat carries the water it separates or lift away from the main body of water (ocean), which it hasn't done here. But one can clearly see on the diagram where the diminishing increase in stability towards Peak curve, because of the deck shape. I'm open for suggestion to my understanding. And the gunwale have buoyancy too.
I had to find out, so I asked something I don't like using. It said:

Screenshot from 2026-09-28 23-34-23.webp
 
Yes it is. I'm not sure how the boat carries the water it separates or lift away from the main body of water (ocean),....

As noted above. The model "thinks" there is a deck, which clearly there isn't.
Thus you need to define the internal shape of the hull, so once the gunwhales are immersed there is a massive change in reserve bouncy for a righting moment....hence the unrealistic GZ curve, rather than the briefly sketched one I show above.
 
I'm not sure I'm following when you say there isn't a deck on the boat when there is a deck on the boat. The boat is a closed volume, and tested as such. The internal shape is the same as outside. The graph should be close to real as regards to the specific 3d model with ballast, since it, as I understand heel the boat in various degrees of positions and makes several Bolean cuts of the submerged area of the hull and measures COB on each cut. The hull as is can really not hold much water at heel, not even as much as the slice in the illustrations above. If what I say here doesn't make sense then I am confused. It does happen.
 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top