What was your plan after this coat, was this the final coat, or were you putting another one over it.
You need a 50/50 mix with the Duratec clear for it to cure tack free, less than that can leave the surface tacky.
Also, did you use the epoxy primer?
Plus polyesters don't bond that well to epoxies, so you have a few things working against you.
My plan was an additional coat (if I'm being honest I should go back to fairing steps - its Bumpy), I still have some lighter spots showing through.
(I'll come back to the duratec suggestion)
I did use epoxy primer. I was reassured (twice) from the maker of the primer that leaving a week to dry prior to shooting gel coat would eliminate any amine interaction issues.
Now, it's been about a decade since I took organic chemistry, but a week for it to surface and a 2x wash + solvent wipe seemed reasonable to mitigate that.
I purchased the gel coat from sea hawk. I think they are just a reseller, not a producer - tough to attest to their qc. Who knows- I am sure its user error.
The gel sets up rock hard in the cup, with a tacky surface on the air facing side.
So, here is what I did- because it was driving me insane.
Wiped down a small panel of the boat with acetone, wet sanded, cut and buffed, then waxed. Turned out ok, but still a bit tacky.
My current plan of attack is this:
1) order new gel and duratec clear
2) "finish" the rest of the boat by the same method described above
3) Get it on the trailer and get my wife her spot back in the garage for mother's day (did the bunks today)
4) get to work on the top side while the duratec and gel ships. Bigger issues up there.
5) re shoot the outside of the boat.
I'm all ears!
Thanks,
-Josh