sail aerodynamics

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest
  • Start date Start date
One other point about headstay sag. The effect of increasing headstay sag is to reduce twist in the headsail. During a gust, the apparent wind increases in strength and shifts towards the beam. It's important that the rig as a whole spills air automatically across all conceivable sail plans. You don't want the jib to flatten. Now if you have a high-cut jib, you can still manage the sail shape, but with high aspect jibs and short sheet leads, you can only make the jib's leach stretch out more than it's head in order to twist off the sail.

This is one of the reasons I have put wire luffs and an effective adjustable downhaul in all headsails that aren't a full hoist. I can fly them at different heights, and I can tension them for harsh conditions (high twist control) and run them slack for stable conditions (low twist, not worried about gust response). I have done this on jibs from 16 to 500 sqft.

Headstay tension (rig tension in general) is a very basic decision that has to be baked in to the hull structural design and has a huge impact on cost and structural weight for smaller craft. Once you start looking at a 10 ton cruiser (say a 40'er) the strength and cost issues of rig tension become a smaller percentage of design worries and production costs. But the point that must be kept in mind is suitability for the intended purpose regarding the crew effort needed to sail well and the degree of gust tolerance that the rig should handle without crew intervention. You also need enough tension for any furlers to function smoothly when trying to furl as you bash your way in through a cut with outgoing tide (think Hell's Gate, Haulover Inlet, or Stiltsville channel.)

The Route du Rhumb has had three capsizes among multihulls in the first 3 days of the race - a classic ORMA (Joyon), a Maxi (LeCeach), and an Ocean Fifty (Perraut). Conditions have been anything but stable, but wind speeds weren't all that high. Gust tolerance is the first thing that gets sacrificed when structural weight gets stripped out of these race boats. Cruisers are expected to be durable, say fifty years hull life. That alone gets you enough hull material to support a decent rig tension. My 38'er ran about 5000 pounds on the headstay at the dock on a 57' stick. Jib sheet tension was similar even when just banging about in the bay. No problem with the jib twisting off in a gust, and I could heel to 35 degrees and just ride stuff out. Matching the performance, ease of handling, and the gust tolerance in a multihull is not easy.
 
I have never had problems with my furlers with a relatively loose rig. How does a loose headstay reduce twist on a headsail? The twist is reduced with vang tension, so a loose forestay wouldn't allow as much tension on it.
 
Yes, I completely agree with you on this.

The modern sloop (2 Sails) was born twice.

It first emerged around 1930 with a 3/4 fractional rig and a backstay.

This backstay was used to bend the mast, flattening the mainsail while simultaneously increasing tension on the forestay.

(This caused the mainsail’s camber to shift aft—which is how the Cunningham came to be.)

It then emerged again in 1947, featuring a masthead rig and a large genoa.

I believe it would be possible to build an ultra-modern 3/4 fractional rig with a rigid mast, where the luff of the staysail is tensioned from below—a method already employed by various performance sailboats.

But I’m actually thinking of a 1-ton craft: something like an exoskeleton or a flying suit, which would be the best solution to prevent a 600-kilogram boom from killing two crew members, as has already happened, along with so many other accidents.
Sydney to Hobart 2024, one boom, one mainsheet. RIP brothers, the Sea Goddess is not to be taken lightly when she's throwing rolling pins.
 
Yes, those mainsails and their handling systems are proving deadly at times. But I don't think that is a reason to eliminate them altogether. They are very efficient sails aerodynamically, and they load the mast tube much more evenly than multiple individually attached stays.

I just chose to eliminate those big tall mains on my CRUISING rig,...a lot of that reasoning for safety from boom strikes and capsize.

What I would like to see is more efforts at alternative methods to control those big mainsails. I think the wishbone type boom has lots of potentials,..(perhaps even on the racing vessels??)
 
What I would like to see is more efforts at alternative methods to control those big mainsails. I think the wishbone type boom has lots of potentials,..(perhaps even on the racing vessels??)
Reef points and sails that are attached with slides instead off a bolt rope on a groove.
 
Sydney to Hobart 2024, one boom, one mainsheet. RIP brothers, the Sea Goddess is not to be taken lightly when she's throwing rolling pins.

Yes

There are a handful of striking cases: this occurred during the Sydney to Hobart race; another, particularly notable, involved a 600 kg (!) boom—though I can’t seem to find the link right now—which killed one person instantly and threw another overboard, making rescue impossible. The boom didn’t stop until it had brought down the entire rig. There have been other incidents in the Atlantic—in Force 7 conditions—which is currently crowded with retirees and those typical, insufferable 45-foot monohull yachts
 
I believe that the design of a yacht should begin by considering the crew—specifically, whether they are professional, semi-professional, amateur, or perhaps just clumsy, ignorant city dwellers.

Furthermore, a sound design—from a technical and scientific perspective—must address the question: how many women will be on board? Whether it’s one, four, or fourteen, this is a crucial variable.

If the yacht is intended for a single person—be it an adventurous youth or a mad old man—then I think the ideal approach would be a one-ton exoskeleton, something akin to a wearable flying suit.

 
Furthermore, a sound design—from a technical and scientific perspective—must address the question: how many women will be on board? Whether it’s one, four, or fourteen, this is a crucial variable.
With fourteen women the tampon locker should be larger. You are an a hole sir.
 
That is a treacherous bit of water, particularly with a lot of big beam seas in the Tasmania sea,...sailing ACROSS the roaring 40's

You could easily see where booms would be a BIG concern.

 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top