Petros
Senior Member
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2007
- Posts
- 2,934
- Reaction score
- 150
- Location
- Arlington, WA-USA
I would not limit it to wood either, except the organization that offered to support the contest is the Center for Wooden Boats in Seattle. they hold sailing excursion, lessons, wood boat building workshops, etc. so they needed a reason to support it. There are similar organizations around the county as well, Mystic Seaport, also here at Port Townsend the Wooden Boat Center, as well as elsewhere. so this would give us an easy way to expand the competition through these organiztions. It would be easier I think to get sponsorship in the future from companies that supply to wood boat builders as well, so we are looking to the future with this competition.
There is also an idea is that perhaps someone might invent a new way to use wood in a hull that would revive wood boat industry. Besides there are many hobby wood workers, not nearly as many fiberglass or metal hobbyists. I can see a lot more people wanting to participate if they can make low cost competitive boats using wood over just about anything else. Wood working tools are relatively low cost, mostly hand tools.
Besides, as a building material there are few things that are cheaper to build with than wood anyway. The composite sheets are still viable under these rules, you just need a wood frame inside it. The rule is the structure must be wood or cellulose based, not the whole boat. If it was going to be a salvaged materials contest, than making it wide open is to be considered (I have entered those kinds of contests too, lots of fun). Except that would mean the designs would not be repeatable for others to build, hence the retail cost only. Using widely available suppliers either from national chains (or at least their prices as a measure of cost) or mail/internet supplier would level the playing field for material costs.
Catbuilder, suggest how the rules could be made simpler? A limited budget, max length width and mast height, and than you go race it, winner is low score for the day. That is it. There has to be a way of measuring the cost of materials fairly across large regions of the country, so it by necessity has to limit where you can buy the materials. Or do you have another suggestion on how to accomplish that?
It occurred to me that rather than a max budget, create a handicap based of cost of materials, so it would favor lower cost boats. But that would complicate it and would compromise the stated intent. You will still have people entering $10,000 boats to blow everyone away, too far off the intent.
The idea is to demonstrate you do not have to spend a lot of money to build good performing boats.
There is also an idea is that perhaps someone might invent a new way to use wood in a hull that would revive wood boat industry. Besides there are many hobby wood workers, not nearly as many fiberglass or metal hobbyists. I can see a lot more people wanting to participate if they can make low cost competitive boats using wood over just about anything else. Wood working tools are relatively low cost, mostly hand tools.
Besides, as a building material there are few things that are cheaper to build with than wood anyway. The composite sheets are still viable under these rules, you just need a wood frame inside it. The rule is the structure must be wood or cellulose based, not the whole boat. If it was going to be a salvaged materials contest, than making it wide open is to be considered (I have entered those kinds of contests too, lots of fun). Except that would mean the designs would not be repeatable for others to build, hence the retail cost only. Using widely available suppliers either from national chains (or at least their prices as a measure of cost) or mail/internet supplier would level the playing field for material costs.
Catbuilder, suggest how the rules could be made simpler? A limited budget, max length width and mast height, and than you go race it, winner is low score for the day. That is it. There has to be a way of measuring the cost of materials fairly across large regions of the country, so it by necessity has to limit where you can buy the materials. Or do you have another suggestion on how to accomplish that?
It occurred to me that rather than a max budget, create a handicap based of cost of materials, so it would favor lower cost boats. But that would complicate it and would compromise the stated intent. You will still have people entering $10,000 boats to blow everyone away, too far off the intent.
The idea is to demonstrate you do not have to spend a lot of money to build good performing boats.