Navier Stokes Solved -

Guilty as charged.

Here's a great introduction to the Euler equations, the Navier-Stokes equations, and what a blow-up into a singularity for both means to mathematicians (apparently a lot) and to physicists (apparently not much):

Why Navier-Stokes Pushes Math and Physics to the Edge

Now we wait to see if an AI 'proof' qualifies as a mathematical proof, or if it's just a model for one!
 
Here's a great introduction to the Euler equations, the Navier-Stokes equations, and what a blow-up into a singularity for both means to mathematicians (apparently a lot) and to physicists (apparently not much):

Why Navier-Stokes Pushes Math and Physics to the Edge

Lewis Fry Richardson said:
Big whirls have little whirls,
That feed on their velocity;
And little whirls have lesser whirls,
And so on to viscosity.

At least the linked Qunata Magazine youtube addressed why soup heats up in a blender....one of my touchstones for fluid theory....

 
CFD is just the cheapest way of predicting the behavior of ships beforehand, which can be (not always is) quite accurate within a tolerance, it's just a tool used by Naval Architects because it's faster and cheaper than model testing. Model testing on it's own is cheaper and faster than full-scale testing. However, full-scale testing is not feasible in time and cost when designing a ship. Sea trials are a requirement to validate the predicted values, but still do not necessarily present the truth as weather- and sea-variables are estimated by humans which are always subjective..
 
For example, an iconic structure like the Golden Gate Bridge or Calatrava's Alamillo in Seville may have arrays of 100's of accelerometers, displacement sensors, and even laser scanners. There might be sufficient data from those to back-check analytical models.
As a bridge inspector, I can assure you we look at the overall structure and focus on stress point or areas that may cause catastrophic failure. For example, the footings usually have some cracks and deterioration. However, on the underwater part of the inspection, I will pay more attention to undermining than to small cracks and delamination. There is no data that matches the billions of points of a simulation. We can compare the observed global behavior to the model's. Also, the more important areas that may get strain gauges installed.
 
There are plenty of tanks that handle models the size of small boats and wind tunnels that will take complete full size rigs. We still come back to the fact that numerical models (as of now) cannot account for all possible 'real world' input conditions and the physical models or at sea testing experiments cannot control with sufficient fidelity many of those same conditions (TBL I'm looking at you!).
There is an axiom that for a model to give the exact data it has to be of the same dimensions as the object it is modeling. That would include the surrounding operating conditions.
 
As a bridge inspector, I can assure you we look at the overall structure and focus on stress point or areas that may cause catastrophic failure. For example, the footings usually have some cracks and deterioration. However, on the underwater part of the inspection, I will pay more attention to undermining than to small cracks and delamination. There is no data that matches the billions of points of a simulation. We can compare the observed global behavior to the model's. Also, the more important areas that may get strain gauges installed.
The factor of safety in bridge design is almost infinitely higher than that of our floating toys.

Trivia regarding inertia; Texas Highway department required bridge inspection reports to be filed in 80 column Hollerith format in the 1990's.
 
The factor of safety would be part of the comparison between the model and the actual bridge. It is irrelevant what the object or factors of safety are. Once a prototype, or a production series exist, the model can be validated or invalidated. In general, we find the boundaries within which models can be used.
 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top