Keel Section

Well I finally managed to get the boat out of the water and had a look at the keel, not a pretty sight! It has been worked on at some stage, smooth but not fair. The foil at the bottom seems to be a 0012 section and the root seems to be closer to a 63-008 section. Should I continue down that path and make it properly fair or is it worth altering the root section to an 00xx section. I clean the keel before every race but it will still be antifouled.
 
Most important is the leading edge. Also the bottom should be well squared or veed, and the bottom front corner should not be rounded in profile so as to compromise the leading edge. The rest of the keel, fair, with a flat squared off trailing edge, but I would not worry too much about matching a NACA perfectly.
 
Trailing edge is also very important. For optimum performance it needs to be thin (a few mm or less). Quite often they are 10-20 mm or even 30 mm thick, which adds 20-100% to the drag of the keel.
 
The trailing edge is about 5mm, but the last 100 mm of the 2000 mm section has on average a 10mm convex shape, some work to be done there.

Having a long chord, I presume that the best course of action is to keep it as thin as possible, that said it does stall out of the tacks when it windy and lumpy so it would seem that some careful attention is needed to the nose shape.
 
Convex is very bad for the last 1/3 of the section. All good sections have straight or concave last 1/3. Many boats with 6-series keel sections use modification with letter A, which means that the last 1/3 is straight instead of being concave, which is would be more difficult to manufacture and not as solid structurally.
 
I managed to take templates and the lower 1/3 of the keel is an 0010 section while near the root is very close to 66-007 gradually tapering into the lower part of the keel and the chord is 1.9m at the root. I was reading in the principles of yacht design that a 63 section is preferred but overlaying that template at the recommended width of 12% means a lot of filler, and even going to a 0007 section is slathering it on! in order to keep any unnecessary work to a minimum and upwind performance, is there any advantage to be had from altering the root section?
 
Last edited:
Whats the best way to practically detail the trailing edge, there seems to be a general consensus that square and sharp is the best but the problem is that antifoul does not stick to corners. Marchaj suggests cutting off 5% of chord length gives no noticeable increase in drag, but on a 2 metre chord that's 100 mm or a 20mm truncation.

attachment.php
 
Number 1, as close as you can get to squared off.
I would risk the fouling there until I experienced it first hand on each specific boat and conditions.

I would try to truncate at less than 5% though. Over time as you barrier coat and fair and so forth the run and trailing edge can really suffer.
It is easier to fair to and square off a trailing edge that trails further to its theoretical point and you can always square it off more if you have some extra to play with.
 
Another, more general question. I recently worked on a new keel design for Laser 28. I analyzed various sections with XFLR5.

With a chord about 0.8m and average speed 3m/s, the Reynolds number is 3,000,000. The keel of a normally used yacht is not very smooth, and the turbulence level near the water surface is rather high, so I assumed Ncrit=1.

With such parameters, it proved to be very hard to obtain any laminar flow. There was no "drag bucket" for any NACA6x series foil. I also failed when tried to design a laminar or semi-laminar foil for these conditions, until it was 22% thick.

For 22% semi-laminar foils (transition at 40-60%) there was a significant drag reduction for AoA up to 4deg. According to XFoil, they are superior over the thin NACA00 foils (while NACA6x laminar ones proved to be worse).

Using a 22% foil section is, however, unusual, and may be risky. So, the question is: are the results by XFoil credible?
If it is actually impossible to obtain laminar flow over the first 40% of the foil chord, it would be better to use NACA0012 or similar.
If my pessimistic assumption about turbulence are wrong, it could be better to use NACA6x series.

What do you think?

regards

krzys

Hi,
I realise I’m bumping an old thread. Apologies in advance. But Myszek, do you know from your experience which naca profile is used on the original Laser 28 keel foil? I’m a current owner and I want to re-fair my keel foil back to template.
 
Hi,
But Myszek, do you know from your experience which naca profile is used on the original Laser 28 keel foil? I’m a current owner and I want to re-fair my keel foil back to template.

The owner of the boat decided for a thin 4-digit NACA with a bulb, carefully designed by Piotr Adamowicz. He is satisfied with this solution, reports a considerable improvements of the performance. So, my work has not been used and tested yet.

regards

krzys
 
Well I finally managed to get the boat out of the water and had a look at the keel, not a pretty sight! It has been worked on at some stage, smooth but not fair. The foil at the bottom seems to be a 0012 section and the root seems to be closer to a 63-008 section. Should I continue down that path and make it properly fair or is it worth altering the root section to an 00xx section. I clean the keel before every race but it will still be antifouled.
Hi,
Naca63012 or naca63015 are excellent for your application.
Induced drag can be reduced if the section @root does not generate any lift. That means using a thinner (relative) profile @root will do. Keeping a 63xxx is a good idea, because that way, you can use thinner profile, but without creating inversion in the keel surface curvature.
 
Hi,
Naca63012 or naca63015 are excellent for your application.
Induced drag can be reduced if the section @root does not generate any lift. That means using a thinner (relative) profile @root will do. Keeping a 63xxx is a good idea, because that way, you can use thinner profile, but without creating inversion in the keel surface curvature.

Thanks this is an old thread and that boat is sold but I have another boat with a similar keel that needs fairing so will review the profiles that you suggest.
 
I have often thought that an improvement to this 1950's design would be to simply truncate at the red line and fair the remaining keel.
keel.jpg
 
"Where did that idea come from"
---

It comes from the interaction between the heeled hull, which brings the keel-root closer to the surface, and the hull wave.

But for it to be a worrying effect, it would have to be a very large-keel-root-on-a-shallow-hull, a very strange combination.

The two known solutions are:

A) A very low aspect ratio Keel on a deep hull

B) A good* aspect ratio centerboard/Keel on a shallow hull

(*: I use this word to avoid the expression "high aspect ratio" (AR > 5) which comes from aeronautics

On sailboats, you can see 0.5 AR keels and the 'high' ones are > 2.5 ARg and 5 ARe = 2 x ARg

g: geometric
e: effectiv

due to the hull effect... an effect that can be completely lost with a Heel greater than 15 degrees in a shallow Hull)

Screenshot_2025-07-10-15-24-10-74.jpg


The Aero- and Hydromechanics of Keel Yachts https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-319-13275-4

JW Slooff

Look

A) Ak = 0.5 with a Deep Hull
B) Ak = 2 with a Shallow Hull

and

C) Ak = 0.5 with a Shallow Hull
 
Last edited:
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top