Another, more general question. I recently worked on a new keel design for
Laser 28. I analyzed various sections with XFLR5.
With a chord about 0.8m and average speed 3m/s, the Reynolds number is 3,000,000. The keel of a normally used yacht is not very smooth, and the turbulence level near the water surface is rather high, so I assumed Ncrit=1.
With such parameters, it proved to be very hard to obtain any laminar flow. There was no "drag bucket" for any NACA6x series foil. I also failed when tried to design a laminar or semi-laminar foil for these conditions, until it was 22% thick.
For 22% semi-laminar foils (transition at 40-60%) there was a significant drag reduction for AoA up to 4deg. According to XFoil, they are superior over the thin NACA00 foils (while NACA6x laminar ones proved to be worse).
Using a 22% foil section is, however, unusual, and may be risky. So, the question is: are the results by XFoil credible?
If it is actually impossible to obtain laminar flow over the first 40% of the foil chord, it would be better to use NACA0012 or similar.
If my pessimistic assumption about turbulence are wrong, it could be better to use NACA6x series.
What do you think?
regards
krzys