To stimulate further engagement with the topic, I have released a revised edition of my thesis. This new version highlights how employing an...
Could I return to an earlier comment of yours on the Circulation thread which I replied to on this thread with the following questions: The...
I couldn't agree more. I have no ides what gas kinetics is, never heard of it, and certainly have never suggested it as part of my thesis. I...
Have I answered your objection at #322 about filling the void at infinite rate? Have I answered your objection at #324 about why I am using the...
To explain the differences between the behaviour of water and the behaviour of air. Is that really your objection to my theory, or are you just...
Nothing in nature occurs at an infinite speed. If I may quote my physics textbook[1]:" It is impossible for conditions in one part of a medium to...
[EDIT] Take another look at the equation. There's no "rapid motion" involved in the calculation of the speed of sound: just γ, R, T and M. Yes,...
This is the most insightful question that has been posed in the 18 months of the thread in which my responses to the objections and questions from...
OK, that is not a reasonable interpretation of my explanation of the source of the low pressure to leeward of the sail (or the top of the wing)....
Yes, indeed, lift and drag are the resolution of the aerodynamic force into two orthogonal components - a straightforward and well-established...
What has this to do with the subject of the current thread?
You have misidentified the object of my mockery. I am not mocking the humility he demonstrates by acknowledging the limit of his knowledge and...
I know this is off the subject of circulation, and I'm sure I have pointed this out before, but there's a big hole in Anderson's book. In a number...
Fun though it is, debunking Prandtl's application of Kelvin's theory of conservation of circulation to aerodynamics is not my primary goal. I...
Unless you have not already done so, before getting totally bemused by his book, watch his video. From around 26:00 he struggles to explain the...
I'm confused. You said "And let's not forget that lift without circulation also happens." Can you give an example of where lift occurs without...
And in a similar spirit, I will respond separately. If I understand correctly, you are suggesting that 100% of the propulsive force generated by...
Not only that, but lift without circulation always happens.
You make a number of interesting statements here, but I'm not sure what your point is. Could I invite you to elaborate please? Why, for example is...
Willam Thomson, Lord Kelvin, introduced the principle of conservation of circulation in the 1860's while working on the field theory relating in...
