

Register  FAQ  Members List  Calendar  Search  Today's Posts  Mark Forums Read  Most Recent Posts  Gallery Images  Search 
 Thread Tools  Search this Thread  Display Modes 
#1
 
 
Stability calc in excel......... Without any software I want to perform the hydrostatic calculations, intact stability Calculations. Has anybody done it in Excel.? Does anyone have such excel spread sheet plz share
__________________ Thanks athvas 

#2
 
 
Perform intact stability calculations in Excel seems like a pretty huge task. Not only is creating a spreadsheet but you have to give it plenty of "macros" created in Visual Basic. Not to mention how to apply the various stability criteria, how to carry out passage to one band studies, wind study and some other studies. If someone has done this, would do well not to share, for free, with others. Anyway, if you find something like that, please tell me how to get it. The hydrostatic calculations would be easier to find but certainly will use very imperfect integration methods (compared to current methods of calculating) for some types of boats: boats with knuckles, transom, bow bulb. Cheers
__________________ My Gallery :http://www.boatdesign.net/gallery/sh...hp?photo=22363 http://657677483.wix.com/tansl 
#3
 
 
Yes TANSL, You r right its a tedious process.... As iam not aware of macros and VB in excell i'm i just wondering if anyone have attempted to do this exercise......
__________________ Thanks athvas Last edited by athvas : 08212013 at 08:47 AM. Reason: Grammatical error 
#4
 
 
Quote:
You need accurate tabulated "Curves of form" and "weights and moments" (from another spreadsheet) it's a numerical solution that's not terribly hard and the inputs are usually limited to normal operational parameters wrt trim and list. I don't have a spreadsheet I can share but it shouldn't be hard to find one, try searching "ship stability spreadsheet". [Added] I just searched, have a look here http://hawaiimarine.com/templates/ they want a few $ but somebody should have a free one there were quite a few floating around before 3D and GHS took off. 
#5
 
 
I have developed applications for conducting naval architecture calculations and, frankly, I think it is impossible to achieve, with Excel, something which rigorously calculate stability in the various loading conditions. Just by making a few silly questions:  How to calculate the corrections to GM due to free surfaces in tanks?  How to calculate the actual equilibrium waterline in each load condition?  How to calculate cross curves of stability? There are several other questions that do not know the solution that could be given with a spreadsheet. Quote:
No doubt that you can make approximations but I have doubts that the accuracy achieved by these approaches could be accepted by the authorities of each country or Classification Societies. Anyway, I will be very, very, happy if someone finds something in Excel, to calculate with the appropriate correction.
__________________ My Gallery :http://www.boatdesign.net/gallery/sh...hp?photo=22363 http://657677483.wix.com/tansl 
#6
 
 
There is a classification society so called Ukrainian Register of Shipping that REQUIRES manual calculations, or use stability software 'approved' by them (that does not exist on the market). Say, they will not accept HST, GHS, Orca or something like that. So for these guys, the calculations are actually made in Excel by taking offsets from lines plan, and by imitation manual calcs. The problem is that such calcs can never consider free trim, thus GZ can be 520% higher than actual, this means an error to dangerous side. We tried many times to explain this issue, but for them seems this great corruption idea...
__________________ http://albatrossdesign.livejournal.com 
#7
 
 
I think it will be necessary to create a program that passes MaxSurf, HST, GHS, Orca, etc.. outputs into an Excel spreadsheet. It will be very usefull for Ukrainian designers. Shall I start working on it?
__________________ My Gallery :http://www.boatdesign.net/gallery/sh...hp?photo=22363 http://657677483.wix.com/tansl 
#8
 
 
Quote:
Don't worry, most of designers from Ukraine already told Register to f*ck off, and work with BV and others.
__________________ http://albatrossdesign.livejournal.com 
#9
 
 
Quote:
It's easy, but takes time to make it perfect for the way you work. Before I did it on hand written booklet, one per project, I have several hundred of these on the basement. Fortunately Excel came over, and I linked my integrator to it. Quite a straight forward set of calculation, and it is far from rocket science. It just need to be very accurate and disciplined and experienced. I think you have to simplifies and not be overwhelm with repetitive calculations. But that my experience, anyone has is own P.S. The StIX (or CE) has seven way to ask the same question. When naval architecture is on the hands of technocrats. 
#10
 
 
dskira, First, I want to express my admiration because I think you had to do a huge job to get something valid with Excel. I do not know what system you use to longitudinaly integrate the values of the sections. If you could describe it, I could get an idea of what the real situation and discuss it with you. Sticking to hydrostatic calculations, which are the simplest, how you calculate the wetted surface of the hull?. This is an interesting topic (naval architecture versus Excel). It suggest me a lot of questions for you. Cheers.
__________________ My Gallery :http://www.boatdesign.net/gallery/sh...hp?photo=22363 http://657677483.wix.com/tansl 
#11
 
 
Actually, I think there is a slight disconnect in what people are talking about here. To develop a "hydro static intact stability booklet" for a ship in Excel (or Lotus 123 for that mater, but Quattro Pro was the best) is fairly easy but, as pointed out, is tedious. The '67 edition of PNA and HSD lay it out in "real" spreadsheet form (for those of you old enough to have used paper spreadsheets) so it is straightfroward. To develop a "hydrostatic intact stability calculation" for a vessel at any displacement or attitude in Excel is another matter.
__________________ A vessel is nothing but a bunch of opinions and compromises held together by the faith of the builders and engineers that they did it correctly. Therefor the only thing a Naval Architect has to sell is his experiences. Last edited by jehardiman : 08222013 at 12:47 AM. Reason: Corrected the Quattro Pro (C) name 
#12
 
 
Quote:
When the earlier computers came along there was a natural shift to a spreadsheets which made life much easier in the small design office. Free surface isn't automatic, it's a manual change in the weights and moments input. And you have to use an iterative approach for equilibrium waterline, but the big problem was that these models were not free to trim. I'd presumed this was a student exercise. The software we have now is so quick relative to the older methods but it's still a numerical method with an iterative solution. 
#13
 
 
#14
 
 
The operations of addition, subtraction, and multiplication (and some other) can be done with Excel. However, the shapes of existing ships make integration procedures we used 30 years ago (Simpson, trapezoids, ...) lead to errors which today are considered unacceptable. These procedures, used in other calculations, such as the wet surface, give rise to errors that can exceed 30%. How can Excel calculate flotation area and its center of gravity in a case like that of Figure 1?. How can calculate with Excel the equilibrium flotation of a boat that is in the situation in Figure 2? How to take into account the appendages volume, some of them only partially submerged? There are plenty of questions but, assuming that these calculations can be performed with acceptable accuracy, is it worth trying?. Never get accurate enough, nor fast, nor cheap
__________________ My Gallery :http://www.boatdesign.net/gallery/sh...hp?photo=22363 http://657677483.wix.com/tansl 


#15
 
 
Quote:
__________________ A vessel is nothing but a bunch of opinions and compromises held together by the faith of the builders and engineers that they did it correctly. Therefor the only thing a Naval Architect has to sell is his experiences. 
Thread Tools  Search this Thread 
Display Modes  

Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Resistance Calc  Anoop_ODL  Boat Design  14  11162009 12:35 AM 
hull speed power calc  nautical  Propulsion  43  05012007 02:35 PM 
Lamination Calc Service  JEM  Fiberglass and Composite Boat Building  1  04272007 10:59 AM 
Formula to calc HP requirements of pontoon  rduval  Propulsion  3  07012006 04:21 PM 
Calc centerboard length  sroberts  Boat Design  1  10062004 08:09 AM 