Best Free or Low Cost Marine Design Software? (2008-2010)

[Fanie]

solidedge are offering their 2D component free

You can get the 2D here. You will have to fill in the thingy to get to the download area.
http://www.plm.automation.siemens.co...2d/index.shtml

If you're using something like Freeship then it is all you need. You can model the hull in Freeship, then export to Solid Edge and cad it up to have the pieces made.

I have a 3D Solid Edge, but the 3D I use very seldom. 99.99% is 2D.

As I understand this 2D is as professional as any out there, so do not think because it is 'free' it is not good, it is professional, just not 3D.

Solid Edge works quite easy too.

[nukisen]

Thanks I will run away to get this one imediately.

[nukisen]

Worked very fine!
Thanks a lot for the suggestion!

[marshmat]

The 2D functionality in SolidEdge is more than adequate for most purposes.

My only beef with SolidEdge is one of their restrictions on the academic version- anything created or edited by a copy running under an academic/educational licence gets locked in such a way that the commercially licensed version can't read it anymore.

[Vulkyn]

I got confused with the similarities between DELFT ship and freeship. Are they the same or different versions?
They even have the same interface and icons ....

Apex said they are basically the same ..... are they both being updated or should i just stick with freeship ? (they cant read each other's files not sure if i exported properly though :S)

[Fanie]

Both are free - Download both and play with them.

I used to use Delftship before then switched to Freeship. Only reason is Freeship has a diffent resistance calculator available.

[marshmat]

Originally Posted by Vulkyn

I got confused with the similarities between DELFT ship and freeship. Are they the same or different versions?
They even have the same interface and icons ....

Apex said they are basically the same ..... are they both being updated or should i just stick with freeship ? (they cant read each other's files not sure if i exported properly though :S)

The original Free!ship forked. Martijn (the original developer) decided to go after the pro/commercial market and renamed that branch Delftship and added a bunch of modules for common tasks in commercial naval architecture. It has a free version that is pretty much the same as older Free!ship versions, and a pro version that can use the powerful NA calculation modules. Free!ship Plus was then spun off by Victor, who has added some resistance prediction codes and other interesting tidbits; this fork is still FOSS and seems to be aimed more at hobbyists and backyard builders.

[Vulkyn]

cheers ill stick to freeship then !

[Fanie]

seems to be aimed more at hobbyists and backyard builders.

Eh Matt, whatch it with the 'backyard' there eh

I'm so glad my build will be in the front...

[Fanie]

Eh Vulkyn,

I read somewhere you guys is Egypt only sail downwind... Is this true

[Vulkyn]

Depends on the wind

[Raggi_Thor]

I think they sail downwind upstream (south) and then drift downstram (north)

[Raggi_Thor]

Fanie, do they ave the same user interface and modelling capabilities, Freeship and Delftship?

btw, I think 178Euros is "low cost" of you need some of the features in Delftship Pro.
I even think Rhino at 900(?)Euros is low cost compared to AutoCAD for example.

I think any tool is low cost if it pays back on one project, so you can buy it when you need it.

[Vulkyn]

Originally Posted by Raggi_Thor

I think they sail downwind upstream (south) and then drift downstram (north)

What exactly do you mean ??
River, Red Sea or Mediterranean or something completely different ??

[Fanie]

What exactly do you mean ??

He's just pulling your leg, that means joking with you. In ancient times no one could sail upwind, so you'd sail upstream and drift back downstream