View Full Version : extreme shoal draft boating


river runner
09-17-2011, 06:28 AM
There are a number of rivers, in the west and elswhere, that can only be boated during a few brief windows a year, and probably not at all some years. One of these rivers is the Dirty Devil, in Utah. I did this one with a solo canoe a number of years ago. I brought along a pulling harness, that I made from a backpack shoulder strap, and the water was frequently so shallow that I had to get out of the boat and drag it for hundreds of yards at a time. Since I was carrying food, water, and camping gear for six days, the load was quite heavy.
A few other rivers like that are the Little Missouri, in North Dakota, and the Escalante in Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument and the Red Deer river in Alberta.
Most people do these with inflatable kayaks or packrafts, but I have give some thought to designing a stitch and glue boat just for floating these rivers. I've kind of decided a cross between a punt and a canoe might be the ticket. Fairly narrow, because the deepest channel is often only a few feet wide, no rocker except at the very ends, flat bottom, slight flair to the sides, pointed or nearly pointed at the ends, or maybe only one end.

Dave Gentry
09-17-2011, 10:33 AM
As I started reading your thread I immediately thought of the Dirty Devil!

I've camped on the rim overlooking that river, and wished I were floating it. I never did because of the difficulties you describe. Beautiful, though.

Minus the pointy bow, I think Jim Michalak already has what you are looking for - check out his Pole Punt or his Ozarkian.
http://www.duckworksbbs.com/plans/jim/polepunt/forjim1.jpg
http://www.duckworksbbs.com/plans/jim/polepunt/index.htm
http://www.duckworksbbs.com/plans/jim/ozarkian/index.htm

portacruise
09-17-2011, 10:38 AM
If you're dragging heavy cargo hundreds of yards over sand that is one thing. But doing same with a wooden boat over sharp rocks is another, maybe use pvc sled? Another thing I have used with pontoon boats is a single custom built flip up/down balloon wheel so the whole thing rolls like a wheelbarrow.

http://www.wheeleez.com/boat-dolly.php

If it is acceptable to do the river in sections to cut the load, some lightweight alternatives are possible.

Hope this helps.

Porta

PS. Is it practical to carry water for a 6 day trip, why not use a water filter like Katadyn?

There are a number of rivers, in the west and elswhere, that can only be boated during a few brief windows a year, and probably not at all some years. One of these rivers is the Dirty Devil, in Utah. I did this one with a solo canoe a number of years ago. I brought along a pulling harness, that I made from a backpack shoulder strap, and the water was frequently so shallow that I had to get out of the boat and drag it for hundreds of yards at a time. Since I was carrying food, water, and camping gear for six days, the load was quite heavy.
A few other rivers like that are the Little Missouri, in North Dakota, and the Escalante in Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument and the Red Deer river in Alberta.
Most people do these with inflatable kayaks or packrafts, but I have give some thought to designing a stitch and glue boat just for floating these rivers. I've kind of decided a cross between a punt and a canoe might be the ticket. Fairly narrow, because the deepest channel is often only a few feet wide, no rocker except at the very ends, flat bottom, slight flair to the sides, pointed or nearly pointed at the ends, or maybe only one end.

Squidly-Diddly
09-17-2011, 08:36 PM
toboggan down wet rocks instead of as floating boat, but was still water tight.

Major 1-2" deep dents EVERYWHERE. Never imagined aluminum could stretch like that. It SEEMED like the metal must have stretched 25% of more to get the extra material for the denting VS flat surface.


Light weight, too, about 130lbs. But hard to find and not cheap when new.

river runner
09-18-2011, 12:16 AM
The Dirty Devil got it's name for a reason. Filtering would be impossible. In fact most of the rivers I run are too full of silt to pump.
Before I went to the trouble and expense of designing, then building, my own design, I'd be wise to look into kits and plans. There are probably several designs out there that would work. One problem with existing designs is that some of the rivers run into a big lake. At the end of the Dirty Devil trip, I had to paddle several miles accross Lake Powell to reach Hite Marina. The boat would have to be up for this too.

LP
09-18-2011, 09:11 AM
Have you considered allowing your water to settle overnight before filtering?

river runner
09-18-2011, 11:41 AM
I did try letting the water settle over night, as an experiment (On the Green River). I also brought along my seven gallon water jugs. I don't reallly remember too much about the result, but I never tried it again and continued to bring my water jugs, so I guess I felt the jugs were a better choice.
On the Dirty Devil, the water is very alkali (did I spell that right?) and the pump doesn't seem to get rid of that (I've backpacked the river too and I pumped some puddles in side canyons). Not to be too gross, but your crap turns green and runny and the water tastes terrible.

SamSam
09-18-2011, 01:55 PM
toboggan down wet rocks instead of as floating boat, but was still water tight.

Major 1-2" deep dents EVERYWHERE. Never imagined aluminum could stretch like that. It SEEMED like the metal must have stretched 25% of more to get the extra material for the denting VS flat surface.


Light weight, too, about 130lbs. But hard to find and not cheap when new.Aluminum is very "sticky" going over rocks and stuff. It also leaves aluminum streaks on rocks, like heel scuffs on linoleum.

View Full Version : extreme shoal draft boating